Morton Sobell

Morton Sobell

Morton Sobell was born into a Jewish family in New York City on 11th April, 1917. He attended Stuyvesant High School, where he became friends with Max Elitcher. (1) In 1934 Sobell became a student at the City College of New York where he studied engineering. While at college he met Julius Rosenberg.

In 1938 Sobell and Elitcher found work at the Navy Bureau of Ordnance in Washington, where they shared an apartment. According to Elitcher, both men joined the local Communist Party of the United States group. In September 1941, Sobell left the Navy Bureau to study for a master's degree at the University of Michigan. Over the next few years they saw each other infrequently.

According to NKVD agent, Alexander Feklissov, Sobell was recruited as a spy in the summer of 1944. "Sobell... was deferred from active military service because he was a top specialist in his field... Sobell was involved in radar engineering and had access to other confidential documents inside GE. Rosenberg recruited him during the summer of 1944 and handled the first two deliveries of documents. Then, very quickly, as with all other members of the secret network, I stepped in to deal with Sobell. The young man I met was of medium height, with dark hair, regular features and expressive eyes. As soon as he spoke, I understood that he was a modest and good person. His simple way of dressing confirmed my impression. When I asked him if he could microfilm his own documents, he replied it was not a problem since he knew photography quite well. At our next meeting I brought him a camera with the necessary accessories and a small stock of film." (2)

Julius Rosenberg

In June 1944 Max Elitcher claimed he was phoned by Julius Rosenberg, whom he had known slightly at college and had not seen in six years. Elitcher later recalled: "I remembered the name, I recalled who it was, and he said he would like to see me. He came over after supper, and my wife was there and we had a casual conversation. After that he asked if my wife would leave the room, that he wanted to speak to me in private." Rosenberg allegedly said that many people were aiding the Soviet Union "by providing classified information about military equipment". Rosenberg said that Morton Sobell was "also helping in this". (3)

At the beginning of September 1944, Elitcher and his wife went on holiday with Sobell and his fiancée. Elitcher told his friend of Rosenberg's visit and his disclosure that "you, Sobell, were also helping in this." According to Elitcher, Sobell "became very angry and said "he should not have mentioned my name. He should not have told you that." Elitcher claimed that Rosenberg tried to recruit him again in September 1945. Rosenberg told Elitcher "that even though the war was over there was a continuing need for new military information for Russia."

Martin Sobell - Soviet Spy

Elitcher claimed that he rejected the idea of being a Soviet spy. A telegram from Stepan Apresyan dated 26th July 1944 gave details of Rosenberg's approach: "In July ANTENNA (Julius Rosenberg) was sent by the firm for ten days to work in CARTHAGE (Washington). There he visited his school friend Max Elitcher, who works in the Bureau of Standards as head of the fire control section for warships... He has access to extremely valuable materials on guns... He is a FELLOWCOUNTRYMAN (member of the Communist Party)... By ANTENNA he is characterized as a loyal, reliable, level-headed and able man. Married, his wife is a FELLOWCOUNTRYMAN. She is a psychiatrist by profession, she works at the War Department. Max Elitcher is an excellent amateur photographer and has all the necessary equipment for taking photographs. Please check Elitcher and communicate your consent to his clearance." (4)

After leaving the University of Michigan Sobell found work with the General Electric Company in Schenectady In 1946 Max Elitcher stayed overnight at the home of Sobell. They discussed their jobs and Elitcher told Sobell he was working on a new gunnery control system. Sobell unsuccessfully tried to get information from Elitcher on this new system. The following year, according to Elitcher, Sobell asked him if he "knew of any engineering students or engineering graduates who were progressive, who would be safe to approach on this question of espionage.

By 1947 Morton Sobell, a qualified electrical engineer, was employed on military work at Reeves Instrument Company in Manhattan. In July 1948, Max and Helen Elitcher stayed with Sobell and his wife in Flushing, while house hunting. One night Elitcher drove Sobell when he delivered a "35-millimeter film can" to Julius Rosenberg who was living in Knickerbocker Village. On the way back Sobell told him that Rosenberg had discussed Elizabeth Bentley, the Soviet spy who had provided information to the FBI.

Max and Helene Elitcher decided to buy a house close to the one owned by Sobell: "The Elitchers bought a house in Flushing, Queens, on the street next to the Sobells'. The two small brick houses were located back-to-back, with easy access through unfenced abutting yards. Max obtained a job at the Reeves Instrument Company, where Morton already was employed. The two men regularly drove to work together; the women shared a jointly purchased washing machine kept in the Sobell basement." (5)

Arrest of Julius Rosenberg

On 16th June, 1950, David Greenglass was arrested. The New York Tribune quoted him as saying: "I felt it was gross negligence on the part of the United States not to give Russia the information about the atom bomb because he was an ally." (6) The New York Daily Mirror reported on 13th July that Greenglass had decided to join Harry Gold and testify against other Soviet spies. "The possibility that alleged atomic spy David Greenglass has decided to tell what he knows about the relay of secret information to Russia was evidenced yesterday when U. S. Commissioner McDonald granted the ex-Army sergeant an adjournment of proceedings to move him to New Mexico for trial." (7) Four days later the FBI announced the arrest of Julius Rosenberg. The New York Times reported that Rosenberg was the "fourth American held as a atom spy". (8)

As soon as he heard the news Morton Sobell, his wife, and two children, traveled to Mexico City and went into hiding. At the end of July, 1950, FBI agents visited Max Elitcher at work. At the time, several former classmates and other associates of Rosenberg's were being questioned and were under surveillance, so there is no reason to assume that Elitcher was regarded initially as an outstanding suspect. However, Elitcher crumbled under questioning and offered to inform on his friends if he was not prosecuted for spying. The FBI put him in touch with Oetje John Rogge, who was also representing David Greenglass.

Martin Sobell was found on 16th August, 1950. According to a statement later made by Sobell, he was kidnapped: "On Wednesday, August 16, 1950, at about 8.00 P.M. we had just finished our dinner in our apartment in Mexico City in the United States of Mexico, and while my wife and I were lingering over our coffee there was a knock on the door. My older daughter opened the door and three men burst into the room with drawn guns and bodies poised for shooting; these men did not ask my name, did not say what they wanted. I demanded to see a warrant, or some other legal process. No reply, except some vague charge... that I robbed a bank in Acapulco in the sum of $15,000,000 was made. Of course, I vehemently denied the charge. I insisted on calling the American Embassy but without being permitted to do so. They picked me up bodily and carried me down from the fourth floor to the ground floor. In the street I kept shouting for the police. A taxi was hailed and they opened the door; tried to force me into the taxi; when two more men came in and beat me over the head with blackjacks until I lost consciousness. I woke up in the taxi and I was stretched horizontally at the feet of the three men." (9)

Ethel and Julius Rosenberg
The arrest of Morton Sobell

Martin Sobell was handed over to the FBI at the Mexican border: "We stopped at the Mexican Customs on the Mexican side of the bridge, across the Rio Grande marking the border. No examination was made of my baggage.... When we reached the bridge... our car was flagged. We stopped and the front door opened. A man entered with a badge in his hand and stated that he was a United States agent and he remained in the car. When we arrived at the United States Customs I was directed to sign a card, arrested after they searched my baggage and myself. They handcuffed me and placed me in jail where I remained for five days, after which time I was taken to New York City."

Trial of Julius Rosenberg

The trial of Morton Sobell, Julius Rosenberg and Ethel Rosenberg began on 6th March 1951. Irving Saypol opened the case: "The evidence will show that the loyalty and alliance of the Rosenbergs and Sobell were not to our country, but that it was to Communism, Communism in this country and Communism throughout the world... Sobell and Julius Rosenberg, classmates together in college, dedicated themselves to the cause of Communism... this love of Communism and the Soviet Union soon led them into a Soviet espionage ring... You will hear our Julius and Ethel Rosenberg and Sobell reached into wartime projects and installations of the United States Government... to obtain... secret information... and speed it on its way to Russia.... We will prove that the Rosenbergs devised and put into operation, with the aid of Soviet... agents in the country, an elaborate scheme which enabled them to steal through David Greenglass this one weapon, that might well hold the key to the survival of this nation and means the peace of the world, the atomic bomb." (10)

The first witness of the prosecution was Max Elitcher. According to the authors of Invitation to an Inquest (1983): "At the trial, Elitcher had to be led frequently by Saypol as he told a story that was vague and improbable. He claimed that Rosenberg and also Sobell had on a number of occasions invited him to engage in espionage activities and that they had continued these requests sporadically over a four-year period - despite the fact that he never had turned over a single scrap of information to them." (11) The New York Daily News reported: "Elitcher left trial observers with the impression that his must have been a masterpiece of equivocation and temporizing, since the first pressure was put to him in 1944... He was still resisting suggestions from Sobell and Rosenberg, he asserted... in 1948." (12)

The only evidence against Morton Sobell was Elitcher's story about the visit to see Julius Rosenberg in July 1948, when he was living in Knickerbocker Village. He described the "35-millimeter film can" that Sobell was carrying but he admitted that he did not know what, if anything, the can contained, nor had he actually seen Sobell deliver it to Rosenberg. Elitcher was unable to say if Sobell gave Rosenberg any information that was secret.

Morton Sobell did not take the stand at the trial. He later this had been a mistake: "I wanted to testify on my own behalf at my trial. I did not do so because my trial attorneys insisted that I should not, because (i) of the fact that the case that the prosecution had put in against me was so weak that my innocence was clearly established; and (ii) that it was so clear that I had nothing to do with any atomic espionage conspiracy.. that it would necessarily follow that I would be freed... I now know I should have insisted on telling my story." (13)

In his summing up Judge Irving Kaufman was considered by many to have been highly subjective: "Judge Kaufman tied the crimes the Rosenbergs were being accused of to their ideas and the fact that they were sympathetic to the Soviet Union. He stated that they had given the atomic bomb to the Russians, which had triggered Communist aggression in Korea resulting in over 50,000 American casualties. He added that, because of their treason, the Soviet Union was threatening America with an atomic attack and this made it necessary for the United States to spend enormous amounts of money to build underground bomb shelters." (14)

Alcatraz

On the morning of Thursday, 29th March, 1951, it was rumoured that one of the jurors was uncertain about the guilt of Morton Sobell. Eventually, the jurors - the dissident vote among them resolved - returned to the courtroom. The jury found all three defendants guilty. Thanking the jurors, Judge Kaufman, told them: "My own opinion is that your verdict is a correct verdict... The thought that citizens of our country would lend themselves to the destruction of their own country by the most destructive weapons known to man is so shocking that I can't find words to describe this loathsome offense." (15) Judge Kaufman sentenced Julius and Ethel Rosenberg to the death penalty and Morton Sobell to thirty years in prison.

Sobell's conviction was upheld by the Court of Appeals early in 1952 by a vote of 2 to 1. Judge Jerome Frank, believed that the case against Sobell should not have been tried jointly with the Rosenberg atom bomb conspiracy and declared that he was entitled to a new trial. Later that year he was transferred to Alcatraz Federal Penitentiary. John Godwin has commented that Alcatraz was the place "to which the Federal government sent prisoners it particularly disliked." (16)

David Caute, the author of The Great Fear (1978) has pointed out: "He was not only convicted and sentenced to an incredible thirty years' imprisonment (of which he eventually served nineteen), he was also sent to the notoriously brutal Alcatraz federal penitentiary in San Francisco Bay. Sobell was one of the few Americans whose confinement equaled in rigor and protraction that of the Soviet political prisoners of the era." (17) Sobell was released in 1969 after serving 17 years and 9 months.

Sobell's Soviet case-officer, Alexander Feklissov, published The Man Behind the Rosenbergs (1999). He admitted that Sobell was a member of the spy network run by Julius Rosenberg. "The Rosenberg network included another agent, who is still alive as I write these pages. His name is Morton Sobell. I used to call him Morty, but his code name at the Center was Senya. Kvasnikov and I gave him another nickname that we thought appropriate because it really described him best: Coy." (18)

Morton Sobell eventually confessed to giving military secrets to the Soviet Union in an interview he gave to Sam Roberts of the New York Times in September, 2008. “What I did was simply defensive, an aircraft gun... This was defensive. You cannot plead that what you did was only defensive stuff, but there’s a big difference between giving that and stuff that could be used to attack our country.” He also admitted that Julius Rosenberg was a spy but rejected the idea that his wife Ethel Rosenberg was a Soviet agent: " “She knew what he was doing, but what was she guilty of? Of being Julius’s wife.” (19)

Primary Sources

(1) Alexander Feklissov, The Man Behind the Rosenbergs (1999)

Sobell... was deferred from active military service because he was a top specialist in his field... Sobell was involved in radar engineering and had access to other confidential documents inside GE. Rosenberg recruited him during the summer of 1944 and handled the first two deliveries of documents. Then, very quickly, as with all other members of the secret network, I stepped in to deal with Sobell. The young man I met was of medium height, with dark hair, regular features and expressive eyes. As soon as he spoke, I understood that he was a modest and good person. His simple way of dressing confirmed my impression. When I asked him if he could microfilm his own documents, he replied it was not a problem since he knew photography quite well. At our next meeting I brought him a camera with the necessary accessories and a small stock of film.

(2) Stepan Apresyan, telegram to Moscow (26th July 1944)

In July ANTENNA (Julius Rosenberg) was sent by the firm for ten days to work in CARTHAGE (Washington). There he visited his school friend Max Elitcher, who works in the Bureau of Standards as head of the fire control section for warships... He has access to extremely valuable materials on guns... He is a FELLOWCOUNTRYMAN (member of the Communist Party)... By ANTENNA he is characterized as a loyal, reliable, level-headed and able man. Married, his wife is a FELLOWCOUNTRYMAN. She is a psychiatrist by profession, she works at the War Department. Max Elitcher is an excellent amateur photographer and has all the necessary equipment for taking photographs. Please check Elitcher and communicate your consent to his clearance.

(3) Morton Sobell, statement (18th August, 1950)

On Wednesday, August 16, 1950, at about 8.00 P.M. we had just finished our dinner in our apartment in Mexico City in the United States of Mexico, and while my wife and I were lingering over our coffee there was a knock on the door. My older daughter opened the door and three men burst into the room with drawn guns and bodies poised for shooting; these men did not ask my name, did not say what they wanted. I demanded to see a warrant, or some other legal process. No reply, except some vague charge that I was one 'Johnnie Jones' and that I robbed a bank in Acapulco in the sum of $15,000,000 was made. Of course, I vehemently denied the charge.

I insisted on calling the American Embassy but without being permitted to do so. They picked me up bodily and carried me down from the fourth floor to the ground floor. In the street I kept shouting for the police. A taxi was hailed and they opened the door; tried to force me into the taxi; when two more men came in and beat me over the head with blackjacks until I lost consciousness. I woke up in the taxi and I was stretched horizontally at the feet of the three men.

When the car stopped in front of a building, they ordered me to get up; they told me to get into the building, but not to make a scene or they would plug me.... we went upstairs, and, we went into an office.

They sat me down and a slim, tall, dark man came over; he looked at me. I asked him what it was all about. He slapped me in the face and told me that they were the ones that were asking questions. At that point I discovered that my head was bloody and my shirt bespattered with blood.

However, they asked me no questions.... We spent in that building from approximately 8:30 P.M. till 4:00 A.M....

At 4:00 A.M. I was moved into a large four-door Packard and seated in the rear with two armed men, one on each side of me. At that moment, the same tall, thin man came to the door and spoke to my guards in English saying to them "If he makes any trouble shoot him."

The driver of the car, who apparently was the leader of the expedition .., told me that they were taking me to the Chief of the Mexican Police for further action. With a number of stops for one reason or another, we drove on until about 6:00 P.M. At that time... the leader tried to make a phone call or he did make one, and he told me that he was trying to get the chief of police. The same thing happened at about 10:00 P.M., and at midnight on August 17th, telling me that he was trying to make sure that the chief of police would be available.

At about 1:30 A.M. we arrived at Nuevo Laredo....

We stopped at the Mexican Customs on the Mexican side of the bridge, across the Rio Grande marking the border. No examination was made of my baggage.... When we reached the bridge... our car was flagged. We stopped and the front door opened. A man entered with a badge in his hand and stated that he was a United States agent and he remained in the car. When we arrived at the United States Customs I was directed to sign a card, arrested after they searched my baggage and myself. They handcuffed me and placed me in jail where I remained for five days, after which time I was taken to New York City.

(4) David Caute, The Great Fear (1978)

The prosecution case against Sobell was that he had agreed and conspired to supply defense data for the use of the Soviet Union (he was not charged with atomic espionage). He declined to take the witness stand and called no defense witnesses; although he pleaded not guilty, he seemed almost traumatized by his predicament. He was not only convicted and sentenced to an incredible thirty years' imprisonment (of which he eventually served nineteen), he was also sent to the notoriously brutal Alcatraz federal penitentiary in San Francisco Bay. Sobell was one of the few Americans whose confinement equaled in rigor and protraction that of the Soviet political prisoners of the era.

(5) Morton Sobell, statement (September, 1953)

My appeals counsel have informed me that at every stage of this proceeding, since the trial, the United States Attorney has stressed in oral argument and affidavit, the fact that I did not take the stand in my own behalf, at the trial. It is highly inappropriate in this case that this fact be given any significance whatsoever, for the following reasons....

I wanted to testify on my own behalf at my trial. I did not do so because my trial attorneys insisted that I should not, because (i) of the fact that the case that the prosecution had put in against me was so weak that my innocence was clearly established; and (ii) that it was so clear that I had nothing to do with any atomic espionage conspiracy.. that it would necessarily follow that I would be freed... I now know I should have insisted on telling my story.

I am completely innocent of the charges made against me. The fantastic tale Max Elitcher told about a wild midnight ride to Julius Rosenberg's apartment is untrue... The balance of his testimony against me, which consisted in not a scintilla more than the insinuation by him of a reference to "espionage" in innocent and routine conversations I had had with him, is likewise untrue.

The only other testimony concerning me at the trial related to a trip to Mexico which I made with my family, which had nothing to do with espionage, and which only after the trial did I realize was given significance by court and jury out of all proportion to what the facts actually showed.... to make the record clear, I want to tell the whole story now.

My wife, daughter, infant son and I left New York in late June, 1950 for Mexico City. This was no suddenly developed plan. I had become dissatisfied with my work in the summer of 1949, but I couldn't very well leave then because I was in the middle of a big project at the Reeves Instrument Company, where I worked. I was in charge of the design and manufacture of a special radar computer known as a Plotting Board, and to have deserted it in midstream would naturally have prejudiced opportunities for future employment. During the following year I investigated several positions but couldn't find anything like what I wanted. I was really interested in getting into more basic research or an academic position.

My project was completed by June, 1950. At about the same time my datighter's school term ended, my wife's graduate physics course at Columbia wound up, and my own course I was teaching at Brooklyn Polytechnic Institute... came to its summer recess. None of us had any special ties keeping us in the city, so we decided to go to Mexico... we had been planning and dreaming of such a trip for several years...

I wrote my employer for an indefinite leave of absence, applied for and obtained necessary visas from the Mexican consul in New York... and bought round-trip tickets at the American Airlines ticket office. On the way, I had the customs officials at Dallas examine and make a record of my foreign-made cameras, so I wouldn't have to pay duty on them when bringing them back into the country. In Mexico City, we rented an apartment for a month or two, where the family stayed all the time we were there.

There was one aspect of the trip, however, which differentiated it from a routine vacation. I was not alone, in mid-1950, in having become apprehensive over signs of political intimidation and repression in this country.... Although a scientist, I was not oblivious to political developments, and in fact, in common with many other scientists, saw a danger to my future in the oppressive atmosphere in which we had to work.

(6) Sam Roberts, New York Times (11th September, 2008)

In 1951, Morton Sobell was tried and convicted with Julius and Ethel Rosenberg on espionage charges. He served more than 18 years in Alcatraz and other federal prisons, traveled to Cuba and Vietnam after his release in 1969 and became an advocate for progressive causes.

Through it all, he maintained his innocence.

But on Thursday, Mr. Sobell, 91, dramatically reversed himself, shedding new light on a case that still fans smoldering political passions. In an interview, he admitted for the first time that he had been a Soviet spy.

And he implicated his fellow defendant Julius Rosenberg, in a conspiracy that delivered to the Soviets classified military and industrial information and what the American government described as the secret to the atomic bomb.

In the interview with The New York Times, Mr. Sobell, who lives in the Riverdale neighborhood of the Bronx, was asked whether, as an electrical engineer, he turned over military secrets to the Soviets during World War II when they were considered allies of the United States and were bearing the brunt of Nazi brutality. Was he, in fact, a spy?

“Yeah, yeah, yeah, call it that,” he replied. “I never thought of it as that in those terms.”

Mr. Sobell also concurred in what has become a consensus among historians: that Ethel Rosenberg, who was executed with her husband, was aware of Julius’s espionage, but did not actively participate. “She knew what he was doing,” he said, “but what was she guilty of? Of being Julius’s wife.”

Mr. Sobell made his revelations on Thursday as the National Archives, in response to a lawsuit from the nonprofit National Security Archive, historians and journalists, released most of the grand jury testimony in the espionage conspiracy case against him and the Rosenbergs.

Coupled with some of that grand jury testimony, Mr. Sobell’s admission bolsters what has become a widely held view among scholars: that Mr. Rosenberg was, indeed, guilty of spying, but that his wife was at most a bit player in the conspiracy and may have been framed by complicit prosecutors.

The revelations on Thursday “teach us what people will do to get a conviction,” said Bruce Craig, a historian and the former director of the National Coalition for History, a nonprofit educational organization. “They took somebody who they basically felt was guilty and by hook or crook they were going to get a jury to find him guilty.”

The Rosenbergs’ younger son, Robert Meeropol, described Mr. Sobell’s confession Thursday as “powerful,” but said he wanted to hear it firsthand. “I’ve always said that was a possibility,” Mr. Meeropol said, referring to the question of his father’s guilt. “This is certainly evidence that would corroborate that possibility as a reality.”

In the interview, Mr. Sobell drew a distinction between atomic espionage and the details of radar and artillery devices that he said he stole for the Russians. “What I did was simply defensive, an aircraft gun,” he said. “This was defensive. You cannot plead that what you did was only defensive stuff, but there’s a big difference between giving that and stuff that could be used to attack our country.”

(One device mentioned specifically by Mr. Sobell, however, the SCR 584 radar, is believed by military experts to have been used against American aircraft in Korea and Vietnam.)

Echoing a consensus among scientists, Mr. Sobell also maintained that the sketches and other atomic bomb details that the government said were passed along to Julius Rosenberg by Ethel’s brother, David Greenglass, were of little value to the Soviets, except to corroborate what they had already gleaned from other moles. Mr. Greenglass was an Army machinist at Los Alamos, N.M., where the weapon was being built.

“What he gave them was junk,” Mr. Sobell said of Julius Rosenberg, his classmate at City College of New York in the 1930s.

The charge was conspiracy, though, which meant that the government had to prove only that the Rosenbergs were intent on delivering military secrets to a foreign power. “His intentions might have been to be a spy,” Mr. Sobell added.



References

(1) Walter Schneir and Miriam Schneir, Invitation to an Inquest (1983) page 121

(2) Alexander Feklissov, The Man Behind the Rosenbergs (1999) page 132

(3) Max Elitcher, testimony at the trial of Julius Rosenberg and Morton Sobell (March, 1951)

(4) Stepan Apresyan, telegram to Moscow (26th July 1944)

(5) Walter Schneir and Miriam Schneir, Invitation to an Inquest (1983) page 324

(6) The New York Tribune (17th June, 1950)

(7) New York Daily Mirror (13th July, 1950)

(8) New York Times (18th July, 1950)

(9) Morton Sobell, statement (18th August, 1950)

(10) Irving Saypol, speech in court (6th March, 1951)

(11) Walter Schneir and Miriam Schneir, Invitation to an Inquest (1983) page 326

(12) New York Daily News (9th March, 1951)

(13) Morton Sobell, statement (September, 1953)

(14) Alexander Feklissov, The Man Behind the Rosenbergs (1999) page 268-269

(15) Walter Schneir and Miriam Schneir, Invitation to an Inquest (1983) page 153

(16) John Godwin, Alcatraz: 1868-1963 (1964) page 168

(17) David Caute, The Great Fear (1978) page 66

(18) Alexander Feklissov, The Man Behind the Rosenbergs (1999) page 130

(19) Sam Roberts, New York Times (11th September, 2008)